When prospects search for CPA expertise today, they're increasingly getting comprehensive answers directly from Google's AI—without clicking through to any websites. This shift in search behavior represents a fundamental change in how firms need to think about digital strategy.
The data confirms what many firms are already experiencing: traditional website traffic from search has declined significantly as Google's AI Mode becomes the default experience. The familiar approach of optimizing for keywords and tracking rankings is becoming less relevant when prospects get their answers without visiting your site.
This isn't cause for panic, but it does require a strategic evolution. The firms positioning themselves for success are those adapting their digital presence for an environment where being cited and referenced matters more than being clicked. Understanding these changes—and adjusting accordingly—is becoming essential for maintaining visibility with prospects.
The search experience your prospects use today would be unrecognizable to someone from just two years ago. Where once they typed keywords and clicked blue links, they now engage in conversations with an AI that understands context, anticipates their needs, and delivers comprehensive answers without requiring a single click.
This shift runs deeper than a simple interface change. For 25 years, search operated on a predictable transaction: users asked, Google pointed, and websites answered. Your digital strategy lived in that final step and your role, as a digital leader, was to optimize your site to be the destination Google recommended. But Google has rewritten the rules entirely. Their AI Mode doesn't point users toward answers anymore; it provides the answers directly, pulling from dozens of sources to synthesize responses that are often more comprehensive than what any single website could provide.
Consider what happens when a manufacturing CFO searches for "R&D tax credit strategies for automated production lines." In the past, they'd evaluate several firm websites, download white papers, and gradually form an opinion. Today, Google's AI instantly synthesizes expert insights, specific strategies, recent regulatory changes, and implementation considerations, all without the CFO visiting a single website. Or perhaps they use ChatGPT and engage in a back-and-forth conversation about these benefits. The AI might reference your firm's expertise, or it might not. Either way, the prospect gets their answer.
This technology isn't just changing where information appears—it's fundamentally altering how prospects evaluate expertise. They're becoming conditioned to expect immediate, comprehensive answers to complex questions. They ask follow-ups conversationally, refining their understanding through dialogue rather than keyword reformulation. Most importantly, they're increasingly making decisions based on these AI-synthesized responses rather than independent research across multiple firm websites.
For CPA firms, this represents a complete inversion of the digital funnel. The battle for a prospect’s attention isn’t just happening on your website—it happens within an AI’s responses: an area that’s largely a black box. From a discovery perspective, your carefully crafted service pages, thought leadership articles, and case studies only matter if the AI deems them worthy of inclusion in its synthesis. And with traffic to websites declining by nearly a third already, this isn't a trend you can afford to ignore.
The digital strategies that have served CPA firms well are becoming less effective—not because they were wrong, but because the digital landscape they were built for is evolving at a pace not seen for years. Traditional digital strategy rests on several assumptions:
While these principles still have merit, they're growing increasingly incomplete. You might rank well for "forensic accounting services" in traditional search but miss prospects who get their information through AI-synthesized responses. Your optimized content still matters, but it matters differently when prospects can get comprehensive answers without visiting your site.
The measurement challenge illustrates this shift clearly. When search results vary dramatically based on user context and history, tracking universal rankings becomes less meaningful. You're not just competing for positions anymore—you're competing for inclusion in personalized AI responses that pull from multiple sources. Tracking that is tricky: only a few, relatively nascent tools exist, and while you can certainly tell whether you’re getting traffic from AI engines, understanding why, and how you can drive more, remains difficult.
Your content investment faces a similar evolution. The thought leadership and expertise you've developed remain valuable, but how it reaches prospects is changing. AI tools might synthesize insights from your content alongside competitors', creating blended responses where individual attribution becomes murky. Your expertise still influences decisions but through different channels than before.
This doesn't mean abandoning what works. Your website has always had to be structured in a way that’s optimized for both algorithms and people: a fact that hasn’t changed. Demand for your firm’s services is unchanged too: AI doesn’t replace the need for an expert tax professional or a team of auditors, but it is rewriting the rules of how clients find you.
While all signs point to AI continuing to play a more and more important role in every element of the business world, the number of visitors to websites from AI search tools isn't expected to surpass the number from traditional search engines until 2028. The shift is gradual but accelerating. Firms that recognize this evolution early can adapt their strategies while maintaining what already works.
The key is building for both worlds: maintaining strong traditional SEO while developing new approaches for AI-driven discovery. It's not about dramatic pivots, but strategic evolution.
The shift in how prospects discover and evaluate firms demands a thoughtful response. Understanding what this means for your firm starts with recognizing what's actually changing and what remains constant.
Prospects still need your expertise. They still face complex tax situations, require audit services, and seek strategic advisory. What's different is how they research these needs.
In this environment, certain realities emerge. Authority and expertise matter more than ever: AI systems prioritize factual, credible content from recognized sources. But that authority must be expressed in ways machines can understand and extract. Local and contextual relevance also gains importance as AI responses become more personalized. A manufacturer in Ohio searching for R&D tax credits might see completely different results than one in California, even with identical queries.
The zero-click phenomenon presents both challenge and opportunity. While prospects might not visit your website immediately, they're often getting more qualified before they reach out. Research from Semrush values the average LLM visitor as being worth 4.4x as much as the average organic search visitor. They've already been educated by AI responses that may include your insights. And when they do contact you, they're further along in their decision process, and more likely to convert.
Success requires evolving how you think about digital presence:
Start with an honest assessment of your current digital assets. Which content truly demonstrates unique expertise versus generic information available everywhere? Where do you have genuine authority that AI systems would recognize as valuable?
Focus your efforts on building what we call "citation-worthy" content—material so authoritative and specific that AI systems naturally reference it when answering related questions. This might be your firm's unique approach to certain engagements, in-depth insights from your experience serving specific industries, or data from proprietary research.
Transform how you structure information. Instead of burying insights deep in long articles, create clear, extractable passages that can stand alone. Think of each section as potentially being the only part of your content that appears in an AI response, rather than just one component of a larger article.
Most importantly, recognize that measurement must evolve. Traditional analytics show only part of the picture now. You need new ways to understand your digital influence: from monitoring AI responses to tracking the quality of prospects who do reach out. The firms adapting fastest are those creating new KPIs that reflect this reality while maintaining focus on what ultimately matters: connecting with clients who need your expertise.
The shift from keyword search to AI conversations is real, it's happening now, and it's already impacting how prospects find CPA firms. While your expertise remains as valuable as ever, how prospects discover that expertise has fundamentally changed.
The trajectory is clear. Firms that adapt their digital strategies now (while maintaining what is already working) will thrive. Those that don't risk invisibility in the channels where prospects increasingly make decisions.
Ready to evolve your digital strategy? Winding River Consulting specializes in helping CPA firms navigate this transition. We'll assess where you stand, chart your path forward, and support you every step of the way.
5 min read
David Toth : Jun 09, 2025
In 2025, accounting firms are investing more than ever in digital marketing: redesigning websites, investing in SEO, launching content campaigns,...
4 min read
David Toth : Mar 20, 2024
In the ever-evolving terrain of professional services, digital strategy stands as a beacon of innovation and progress. Yet, it's often relegated to...
3 min read
David Toth : May 13, 2021
Reprinted with permission from Accounting Today. 2020 changed everything about how businesses operate, including how they interact with everyone...
David Toth